[arin-ppml] Petition Underway - Policy Proposal 95: Customer Confidentiality - Time Sensitive

[David Farmer]

Thanks, Ted that was a good summary.

Ted Mittelstaedt wrote:
> Naturally the AC will need to make the "official" determination
> but it looks like we will be discussing this.
Actually that is Staff's job, if the AC did that, it would be the fox 
guarding the chicken coop.  The the Staff is much better at counting 
then us on the AC anyway, you know they have to count out each IP 
address right, just like a teller does at the bank. :)  Talk about a 
barrier to IPv6 adoption. :)  (only kidding)  ARIN Staff is great!!!

But, I believe most of the AC was watching, I know I was.
> Marshall your arguments! :-)
And yes you should do that, may I suggest everyone take a step back and 
take a breath first.

So, a little more serious now;

I would like to ask the community to think about how we all want this to 
work.  Personally, I've been waiting for the petition process to kick 
in. I actually think it is a healthy thing and shows the process is 
working.  But, we are setting precedent, this is the first petition for 
the new PDP, so lets try to make it good precedent and all do our part 
to make the system work.  The first use of the Emergency PDP last year, 
wasn't the greatest experience for our community.  I would hope we can 
make this first a much better experience for us all.

And we all will play a part in making it a good experience.

This got people charged up, but could you use a little of that energy 
and look that the other proposals, 101, 106, and 107.  The AC need to 
finish up the text for these to go to staff and legal review, by EOB 
Monday. 
 
PP#101 has new language I sent out a couple days ago.

PP#106 Scot and I are working on, and would hope we get some new text out.

PP#107 I will be sending some more changes shortly based on feed back 
from the staff clarity review.

Thanks and I hope to see many of you in Toronto.

-- 
===============================================
David Farmer               Email:farmer at umn.edu
Networking & Telecommunication Services
Office of Information Technology
University of Minnesota	       
2218 University Ave SE	    Phone: 612-626-0815
Minneapolis, MN 55414-3029   Cell: 612-812-9952
===============================================