[arin-ppml] ARIN-2024-10: Registration Requirements and Timing of Requirements With Retirement of Section 4.2.3.7.2

[Alicia Trotman]

Good Evening,

In case you missed it, below is a summary of the feedback received for ARIN
2024-10: Registration Requirements and Timing of Requirements With
Retirement of Section 4.2.3.7.2  at  ARIN 55.

A few  questions were asked at the end of the presentation, first question
related to extending the registration requirement from 7 to 14 calendar
days. Second question asked, should Section 6.5.5.2 should be absorbed into
Section 6.5.5.1?

Here are some comments received following the presentation:

Positive Comments:


   - Support for the policy as written, with the 14 day change. It was
   noted that Section 6.5.5.2 should not be collapsed into section 6.5.5.1 at
   this time. If it does, that should be a separate policy proposal in the
   future.
   - Support  for the policy with some additional work that definitely
   could go on. It was stated there’s no difference between 7 and 14 days, an
   organization that is not putting in SWIPS doesn’t care whether it’s 7 or 14
   days but for those that are doing it, 14 is more reasonable when they’re
   dealing with manual processes, etc. The one thing that  would make the
   biggest difference in this policy is changing the arbitrary/29 to something
   more reasonable more realistic like/24 it is believed that the uptake of
   records would improve. When we weren’t SWIPING things, that made sense 20
   years ago that don’t make sense now ,so the biggest improvement to this
   policy is to increase the size of what is required to be SWIPed so that
   we’re not dealing with minute portions of space.
   - Support this policy as written, since things move slowly, technically
   administratively in the Caribbean and extending the window to 14 days will
   benefit small island states. Additional support for the sake of consistency
   between Section 4 and 6.
   - Support for the policy as defined, reducing confusion around the seven
   or 14 day is a positive change.
   - Support for the policy as drafted. Sections 6.5.5.2 and Section
   6.5.5.1 should not be combined, however I have no preference regarding 14
   or seven days. If folks aren’t submitting in seven days they won’t start in
   14.


Opposing Comments:


   - Seven day window should stay. Timely updates help enforcement and
   network operators by keeping the registration data accurate. Extending to
   14 days could cause delays and reduce the reliability of the data unless
   there is a clear need for a change.
   - "Directory Service" could be taken out of context, in addition,  the
   text could be misleading.  "Approved Directory Service" is suggested as a
   replacement of the current text."

We welcome your comments.

Regards,
Alicia and Lily
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.arin.net/pipermail/arin-ppml/attachments/20250514/2af429ac/attachment.htm>