[arin-ppml] ARIN-PPML 2015-2

[David Huberman]

> That's only true if everybody is playing by the same rules. I asked, but I still
> haven't heard someone explain the CNNIC rules and process that facilitate
> IPv4 addresses transferring out of China and over to North America.
> Reciprocity is something of a requirement for free trade.

I didn't see this question.  Our experience has been we can move space from CNNIC to APNIC, and then APNIC has reciprocity with ARIN.  So CNNIC has reciprocity with ARIN via APNIC (just like ARIN to CNNIC has to first go through APNIC).