[arin-ppml] Initial ISP Allocation Policy

David Huberman David.Huberman at microsoft.com
Mon Jul 22 11:26:03 EDT 2013


Thank you for moving this discussion to the next step by providing excellent draft policy proposal text (and providing a redlined PDF).  I support this draft text.  I have two comments for your consideration:

1) Since we're cleaning up NRPM, let's remove section "4.2.2 Annual Renewal".  This text does not help answer the question, "Do I qualify for number resources from ARIN?" and is already sufficiently covered by the RSA text.

2) The SWIP section ( Reassignment Information): the way the new text is written, it seems to me that if $ENTERPRISE assigns a /28 to a $PURPOSE, that has to be SWIPed.  Would the text be improved if the opening sentence read, "Each IPv4 assignment to an external customer" or somesuch?

With regards,

More information about the ARIN-PPML mailing list