[arin-ppml] Draft Proposal 2011-1 - Comments request - Globally Coordinated Transfer Policy

[Bill Darte]

Thanks Bill.
This is excellent feedback and gives a very concise starting point for more discussion.
Others?  Please follow's Bill's lead here.
 
For or Against...as is
What could be improved with the original...or Bill's very understandable alternative.
 
Thanks to all,
 
bd-

________________________________

From: wherrin at gmail.com on behalf of William Herrin
Sent: Fri 5/13/2011 5:08 PM
To: Bill Darte
Cc: arin ppml
Subject: Re: [arin-ppml] Draft Proposal 2011-1 - Comments request - Globally Coordinated Transfer Policy



On Tue, May 10, 2011 at 1:34 PM, Bill Darte <BillD at cait.wustl.edu> wrote:
> The policy text reviewed at the meeting was as follows:
> Any RIR's resource registrant may transfer IPv4 addresses to the resource
> registrant of another RIR as long as the two RIRs agree and maintain
> compatible, needs-based transfer policies that exercise Internet stewardship
> consistent with the values expressed in RFC2050.
>
> 1. Identify support or objection

Hi Bill,

Oppose.

> 2. If objections exist, to succinctly identify what they are..and,

a. I'm not convinced we should be contemplating inter-region transfers
prior to ARIN's free pool exhausting.
b. I'm not convinced *any* of the 5 RIRs adhere to RFC2050's "values"
except in a very loose way... which makes it a weak and subjective
place to hang a policy.


> 3. How objections might be concisely remedied in text

"ARIN shall permit the transfer of IPv4 addresses between ARIN
registrants and registrants of other RIRs provided that:

a. Both ARIN and the other RIR agree to the transfer,
b. ARIN and the other RIR have functionally reciprocal inter-region
transfer policies, and
c. Both the offering and receiving registrants qualify for the
transfer under ARIN's normal intra-region resource transfer policies
save that one of the registrants is not in the ARIN region and will
therefore not be under contract to ARIN."

Regards,
Bill Herrin




--
William D. Herrin ................ herrin at dirtside.com  bill at herrin.us
3005 Crane Dr. ...................... Web: <http://bill.herrin.us/>
Falls Church, VA 22042-3004


-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.arin.net/pipermail/arin-ppml/attachments/20110514/9976f37c/attachment.htm>