[arin-ppml] Final draft of 2010-13 for Atlanta (Rev 1.55)

[Hannigan, Martin]

On 9/30/10 9:44 AM, "Owen DeLong" <owen at delong.com> wrote:

>> 
>> I don't believe that we're saying anything different with respect to
>> inequities. Look at it from this perspective; if you have 1M /28
>> reservations and you have 1 x /18 reservation, in order to fulfill all or
>> most of the /28's you'll eat away at the /18.
>> 
> And if you have 1,000 /25s and 1 /18 you'll eat away at the /25s in order
> to give something to the /18 guy. Correct. Not giving the entire available
> space to the first guy in line just because he got there a couple of hours
> ahead isn't my idea of unfair.


Ah, no. The theoretical /25's and /18's would have been approved based on
need. An equal reduction for all bolsters the equity of needs based
allocations. Capping the reduction on the low side is the Robin Hood
approach. 


Best,

-M<