[arin-ppml] Is Emergency action warranted for Policy Proposal 123: Reserved Pool for Critical Infrastructure?

[Hannigan, Martin]

Milton,

NRPM Section 4.4 is the scope for this proposal and it is clearly defined.
In fact, I specifically narrowed the intent to support 4.4 to limit
"interpretations".



Best,

-M<


On 12/7/10 1:28 PM, "Milton L Mueller" <mueller at syr.edu> wrote:

> Is the definition of "critical infrastructure" sufficiently clear such that it
> can be applied unambiguously?
> Only definition I can find is NPRM 6.10.1. Do we have a precise definition or
> understanding of what is a "public exchange point" and a "core DNS service
> provider"? In a world of 5,000 TLDs, do all g and cc TLDs have the same
> status?  
> two purposes, something that might occur if there was just one pool",