[arin-ppml] Draft Policy 2009-1: Transfer Policy - Revised andforwarded to the Board

[Roger Marquis]

Ted Mittelstaedt wrote:
>> Rather than helping the problem the fact that this market is
>> being discussed is exactly what is causing the hoarding.
>
> I have to cry foul with this.  There's been implications
> of hoarding on this list and in the last meeting but I have only
> seen a single allegation posted on this list of an illigitimate
> IPv4 holding, and that was a year ago.  (and it wasn't a hoarding
> situation)

If hoarding includes large netblocks (mainly /16s) that are not used and/or
not needed I can name several, and even a cursory audit will show dozens.

> Since true hoarding implies false data submitted for an IPv4

This may be a source of confusion.  Hoarding does not imply false data
submitted for an IPv4.

Roger Marquis