Policy 6 - Single organizations with multiple aggregation poi nts

[Huff, Mark]

* When applying for additional address space, from an RIR, for new
networks or additional space for existing networks the organization must
show greater than 50% utilization for the last block granted by the RIR
and their allocations as a whole.  Any reserved blocks must be allocated
to a discrete network before the RIR will grant additional address space.


This requirement defeats the purpose. If overall usage is measured then
the minimum assignment by the RIR, currently /20 needs to be increased.
If I am expected to rob from one network to support address depletion 
in another the blocks must be globally routable.


mark huff
integra telecom





-----Original Message-----
From: Andrew Dul [mailto:andrew at internap.com]
Sent: Wednesday, October 31, 2001 6:25 AM
To: ppml at arin.net
Subject: Re: Policy 6 - Single organizations with multiple aggregation
points


Here is the revised text after discussions yesterday.

------

ARIN VIII - Policy Proposal 6
Single organizations with multi-homed discrete networks

Criteria for the application of this policy:

* The organization should be a single entity, and not a consortium of
smaller independent entities.  (Example: Not a group of independent
network operators who form a group specifically for this policy)

* This policy applies only to organizations that have been previously
granted address space by an RIR.  This policy does not apply to
organizations with only legacy address space.

* The organization must have multiple (at least two) discrete multi-homed
networks.

* The organization should have a compelling criteria for creating discrete
networks.
	Examples: 1) regulatory restrictions for data transmission
                  2) geographic distance and diversity between networks
                  3) autonomous multi-homed discrete networks

* An organization which would like to use this policy must apply for this
policy to be applied to their maintainer account.

Requirements for additional allocations from RIR:

* The organization must record allocations or assignments down to the
current RIR bit boundary (currently /29 for ARIN) and record them in an
approved RIR public database.

* The organization must keep detailed records of how it has allocated
space to each discrete network.  This should include the block allocated,
any reserved blocks, and date of allocation/reservation.  The discrete
network allocation information should also be present in a public database
(Example:  routing registry, rWhois, or SWIP).

* The organization must not allocate additional space to a discrete
network unless all the blocks allocated to that network show utilization
greater than 80% individually and as a whole.

* The organization must not allocate a CIDR block larger than the current
minimum assignment size of the RIR (currently /20 for ARIN) to a new
network.

* The organization must not allocate an additional CIDR block larger than
the current minimum assignment size of the RIR (currently /20 for ARIN) to
an existing network, unless previous growth rates for that network
indicate that it is likely to utilize a larger CIDR block before the time
the organization will be requesting an additional block from the RIR.
The suggested minimum allocation size for an additional block for a
network is the current minimum assignment size of the RIR.

* When allocating a block larger than the minimum assignment size to an
existing network the organization should use the smallest allocation
possible out of a larger reserved block.  This requirement is to reduce
the number of routes the organization will announce from that autonomous
system.  Example:  A fast growing network is allocated a /20 out of a
reserved /19, when the /20 is 80% utilized the announcement is expanded to
a /19 and the /20 announcement is removed.  This practice also allows the
reserved /20 to be used by another discrete network should the 'fast
growing network' not use the address space as anticipated.

* When applying for additional address space, from an RIR, for new
networks or additional space for existing networks the organization must
show greater than 50% utilization for the last block granted by the RIR
and their allocations as a whole.  Any reserved blocks must be allocated
to a discrete network before the RIR will grant additional address space.

* The organization must follow guidelines of RFC 2050 (or its replacement)
and the policy of the granting RIR for allocations that are assigned or
allocated to downstream networks.  This includes record keeping of
allocation and reassignment requests and network utilization documents for
audits by the RIR.