From memsvcs at arin.net  Tue Nov  2 10:34:04 1999
From: memsvcs at arin.net (Member Services)
Date: Tue, 2 Nov 1999 10:34:04 -0500 (EST)
Subject: Database Implementation WG - Notes from Denver
Message-ID: <199911021534.KAA23528@ops.arin.net>

As promised, here are the notes for the Database Implementation
Working Group discussion held October 19th, 1999 at the Denver
Marriott City Center as part of ARIN's Public Policy Meeting:

Topics of Discussion:
---------------------
1. SWIP and in-addr.arpa authentication procedures
2. RWHOIS technology
3. Improvements to SWIP
4. Potential re-use of historically-unique network registration handles
5. Publically-accessible customer information/reassignments
6. Possible additions to POC fields in ARIN's WHOIS

Attendee List:
--------------
petrovic at corp.earthlink.net (Mark Petrovic)
martind at uu.net (Dawn Martin)
dploher at level3.net (Darren Loher)
kjh at cert.org (Kevin Houle)
pwilson at apnic.net (Paul Wilson)
jason at pathwaynet.com (Jason Smith)
mike at coloradocomputing.com (Mike Booco)
Fran.Lamerson at eds.com
Tanya.Hinman at cwusa.com
Ron.Muir at corp.bellsouth.net
gene at netreach.net (Gene Jakominich)
algold at co.rnp.br (Alexandre Grojsgold)
mike at netwright.net (Michael Lieberman)
repete at cncx.com (Pete Bowden)
awm at cv.net (Aram Mirzadeh)
david at qwest.net (David Kessens)
markk at netsol.com (Mark Kosters)
dcheline at telocity.net (Doug Cheline)
linda at sat-tel.com (Linda Werner)
rogerh at arin.net (Roger Halls)
kerr at arin.net (Shane Kerr)
michaelo at arin.net (Michael O'Neill)

1. Improvements to SWIP & reverse server security
-------------------------------------------------

   * Right now ARIN's systems and analysts review only <MAIL-FROM:>

   * Discussion and suggestions for password storage and web-based
     updates

   * Any improvements to ARIN's authorization and authentication system
     would facilitate ISPs' control over reassigments (SWIPs) and
     in-addr information in network records

   * ARIN staff will communicate a proposal to:

       1. change (based on RIPE-121 and RIPE-189 authentication and
	  authorization) for ARIN maintainer database

       2. request input from dbwg e-mail list and membership on these
          changes

       3. send RIPE document links to DBWG.

       4. post a link to relevant RIPE documents on ARIN web-site

2. RWHOIS
---------

   * The group discussed RWHOIS mirroring and client functions

   * Mark Kosters reported on the state of RWHOIS development, bug
     fixes, and progress toward version 2.0 of the software by Network
     Solutions engineer David Blacka <davidb at netsol.com>

   * Shane Kerr will propose a list of near-term fixes to ARIN RWHOIS
     contributions to include

       1. checking up on root.rwhois.net forwarding

       2. impact of registering external RWHOIS servers with ARIN RWHOIS

       3. publish RWHOIS information and links on ARIN web page

       4. initiate ARIN RWHOIS web page

       5. incorporate information about future updates to RWHOIS client
          from www.rwhois.net developers into ARIN web page

       6. investigate any updates to mirrored server capabilities

       7. request input from broader ARIN membership to determine level
          of interest and priority in future ARIN RWHOIS efforts

3. SWIP (Shared WHOIS Project)
------------------------------

   * ARIN members reported problems with deletion failures

   * ARIN staff to investigate a new parser to allow members to parse
     with "on-demand" error reporting - Pete Bowden has forwarded
     ARIN staff with some older code to do some SWIP parsing. ARIN
     staff will investigate the utility of this program.

   * ARIN staff to fix a problem with subject line changes that attach
     only "Re: Your Mail" when auto-replying to SWIP

4. Potential re-use of historically-unique network registration handles
-----------------------------------------------------------------------

   * Group supported a change to database to allow re-use of network
     handles

   * ARIN staff to investigate impact on registration software and
     report back via e-mail to dbwg e-mail list

5. Public registration of reassignments
---------------------------------------

   * RFC 2050 information for assignments required in both SWIP and
     RWHOIS

   * Policy group and members need to address concerns about ISPs' need
     for customer data protection

   * Revisions to RFC 2050 should account for privacy,
     competition, and operational concerns

6. Extend POC information
-------------------------

   * ARIN staff will investigate extension of POC information
     associated with network number records to include abuse and NOC
     contacts

   * ARIN staff will also investigate how any new POC information
     would impact templates and existing contact database

If you have any addition to these notes, please feel free to post
them to this dbwg mailing list or e-mail them to:
	member-services at arin.net

Don't forget: if you are looking for a complete listing of those
subscribed to dbwg at arin.net, you can send an e-mail to
majordomo at arin.net with "who dbwg" in the body of the e-mail (without
the quotes).

Regards,

David R Huberman,
Membership Services Coordinator
American Registry for Internet Numbers