From info at arin.net Fri May 10 15:34:29 2024 From: info at arin.net (ARIN) Date: Fri, 10 May 2024 15:34:29 -0400 Subject: [ARIN-Suggestions] One New Suggestion Received Message-ID: One new suggestion has been received (2024.8). You may find the new suggestion and link in full below. Regards, American Registry for Internet Numbers (ARIN) --------- ACSP Suggestion 2024.8: Increase Length Limit on IRR Remarks Field https://www.arin.net/participate/community/acsp/suggestions/2024/2024-08/ Author: Dale Carder Description: Increase IRR ?Remarks:? field length limit, and/or allow multiple ?Remarks:? fields Value to Community: When we were trying to migrate our AS-SET records from a 3rd party non-authoritative registry to the ARIN IRR, we found there appears to be a length limit of 1024 on the remarks field. Our motivating use case for this is primarily that Lumen (Level3) AS3356?s filtergen system can not do cross-registry lookups, so they implement a proprietary ?Remarks: Level3 members:? syntax to explicitly enable specification of member objects prefixed with the registry they are located in. This field then overrides the standard RPSL ?members:? field in an AS-SET. As the majority of our downstream customers are in 3rd party non-authoritative registries and that we want to facilitate them moving their data to authoritative registries, particularly the ARIN IRR, this means that we end up with a fairly large set of remarks we need to include as well as duplicates for any ASN that may records in multiple databases. It would be straightforward to maintain this amount of data in one object as we previously did on the other IRR server that supported multiple remarks fields. At present, we have had to chain together multiple AS-SET records to overcome this length limitation in ARIN?s IRR. Additionally, it is often seen that networks document other items such as routing policies, supported bgp communities, and other items relevant to BGP peering in the remarks field. These also are often found to exceed 1024 characters. As we want to facilitate networks migrating to authoritative IRR servers, the ARIN community may increasingly need feature parity. Status: Confirmed From info at arin.net Thu May 30 10:38:35 2024 From: info at arin.net (ARIN) Date: Thu, 30 May 2024 10:38:35 -0400 Subject: [ARIN-Suggestions] New Response from ARIN for Suggestion 2024.7 Message-ID: <0FDEC3CA-C224-401F-BC02-4246A821CEDA@arin.net> A new response from ARIN has been posted for Suggestion 2024.7. Find the original suggestion and latest response from ARIN below. Regards, American Registry for Internet Numbers (ARIN) --------- ACSP Suggestion 2024.7: Create Mandatory Mailing List for General Members https://www.arin.net/participate/community/acsp/suggestions/2024/2024-07/ Author: Andrew Dul Description: Create a general member mailing list that all general members are subscribed to as a requirement of being a general member. Value to Community: Currently the general-members list does not contain all the members. Today this list only contains about 10% of the members. It would be useful for ARIN and other general members to be able to communicate with all members in some circumstances. Initial suggestion would be for the list to be announce type list where ARIN is the only authorized poster. It might also be useful to consider if the list could be a moderated list in the future, if desired by the whole general member community. Status: Open ARIN Comment: Thank you for your suggestion, numbered 2024.7 upon confirmed receipt, recommending that ARIN automatically subscribe General Members to a mailing list as a requirement of General Membership. From 1999 to 2021, ARIN operated the ARIN Discussion mailing list as an auto-subscribed list for all ARIN member organizations. Since this list?s retirement in 2021, ARIN has adopted the position of all our mailing lists being opt-in only. This change was made to respect member preferences and privacy, ensuring that all subscribers are genuinely interested in the content and fostering more engaged and meaningful discussions. ARIN General Members are encouraged to subscribe to the General Member Mailing List, which is open to only General Member organizations and is intended for discussions relevant to ARIN?s governance. While we do not plan to require General Members to subscribe to the General Member Mailing List, we will augment the General Membership request form in ARIN Online to highlight availability of the General Member mailing list and allow requesting subscription to the list at the time of general membership request. Your suggestion will remain open until we implement improvements to the General Membership request form. Thank you for participating in ARIN?s Consultation and Suggestion Process.