[ARIN-Suggestions] New ACSP Suggestion and Response for 2022.15
info at arin.net
Thu Jun 16 09:51:29 EDT 2022
One new suggestion was recently submitted to ARIN’s Consultation and Suggestion Process (ACSP). Find the original suggestion and ARIN's response below:
ACSP Suggestion 2022.15: Add Ability to Remark a Geofeed URL
Description: Please add the ability to remark a geofeed URL like other RIR’s allow. A commonly accepted method is to use Regional Internet Registries (RIR) such as AFRINIC, ARIN, APNIC, LACNIC, or RIPE to share geofeed URLs by adding a remarks attribute with value Geofeed (https://your-url.com/geofeed.csv) when you define an inetnum entry. This way, IP geolocation providers such as Ipregistry can discover new geofeeds when they parse Whois databases periodically. Outlined - https://ipregistry.co/blog/geofeeds
Value to Community: It would allow for ISPs to update their geolocation details via a geofeed rather than contacting each IP geolocation website. This is offered by other Internet Registry services.
Timeframe: Not specified
ARIN Comment: Thank you for your suggestion, numbered 2022.15 upon confirmed receipt, requesting that ARIN add the ability to include a geofeed URL using inetnum: objects in the Authenticated. This suggestion is similar to suggestion 2021.27 (https://www.arin.net/participate/community/acsp/suggestions/2021/2021-27/).
We investigated the usage of inetnum: objects, prior to the creation of the ARIN authenticated IRR, and found usage of inetnum: was extremely limited, and inclusion of geolocation coordinates was not detected. This factored into our original decision to discontinue support for inetnum: objects when the ARIN authenticated IRR was created. We researched other RIRs, and 3rd party IRR operator databases for inetnum: objects populated with geo coordinates, the count ranged from statistically insignificant to zero. There are several alternatives for publishing this data, including but not limited to, using a remark in an existing route: object and populating it with the link to your Geolocation feed. This mitigates the need to restore support, create and maintain new inetnum: objects.
As there are alternative ways available to publish geolocation data that do not necessitate restoring inetnum: to the ARIN IRR, we are not going to pursue development of this suggestion. Thank you for participating in ARIN’s Consultation and Suggestion Process.
The American Registry for Internet Numbers (ARIN)
More information about the arin-suggestions