[arin-ppml] ARIN 58 Table Topic - If the Waitlist didn’t exist, what would?

[Fernando Frediani]

Hi

ARIN auctioning off IPv4 is something unthinkable for a RIR. I don't 
even understand how people come up with these ideas. RIRs are not 
brokers and are never meant to be anything like that.

I believe the whole issue around waiting list is that people ... have to 
wait. And they don't want to. Some believe that if putting money on the 
table they can get a fastpass in front of others and get what they need.
But Numbering Resources managed by a RIR are a shared resource and was 
never meant to be treated as a private asset, but to serve the internet 
community from that region and as such should be assigned to those who 
need and have justification to receive them, regardless of their 
economical power.

Waitling list is a natural and the fairest thing to do with recovered 
addresses, even though it can be a long wait, at least they go to those 
who have the most right both because they can justify the need under the 
current policy and also because they have been patiently waiting in the 
list. What else one would expect to be ?
I find hard to believe that people expect the waiting list resources to 
be the salvation to their internet business (those who have some 
resources already).

I am personally of the opinion that waiting list should assign space 
only to newcomers, therefore those who have nothing to begin with as in 
other RIRs like LACNIC. Those who have something have means for revenue 
to acquire a block later when necessary.
But until that change just leave the waiting list as it is to keep the 
most fair way to allocate that IP space.

Regards
Fernando

On 10/27/2026 10:09 AM, Jones, Brian wrote:
> At ARIN 58 the NRPM Working Group introduced this table topic and garnered a bit of discussion about the community’s thoughts concerning the Waitlist. Posting here for broader exposure and to solicit more community feedback.
>
> _________________________________________________________________________________
> Table Topic - If the Waitlist didn’t exist, what would?
>
> Discussions about how ARIN would handle the return of IP address space became a central topic.
>
> There was much discussion around auctioning off IPv4 addresses after that topic was brought up. It was pointed out that there are legal and ethical issues to consider for what ARIN would do with and resources from this. There was discussion about how the money would be used if such a decision was made to auction off IPv4 address space.
>
> It was expressed that no new policy would have to replace the Waitlist, that by default ARIN would continue allocate IPv4 address space out of section 4.4 and 4.10 of the NRPM and that IPv4 resources would be replenished with any returned or reclaimed resources to the reserved pools as is indicated by the NRPM.
>
> There were also discussions about combining sections 4.4 and 4.10 of the NRPM and removing the Waitlist while also relaxing the requirement for acquiring these resources concerning transitioning to IPv6. Relaxing the requirement from you must have an IPv6 transition plan to acquire any resources from this space to something like “with preference given for those transitions to IPv6”. The hard requirement for transitioning to IPv6 was brought up as an impediment for those who may not have the money for purchasing newer network equipment to support IPv6 and at least in some Caribbean regions it may take the local government involvement before network operators can even consider moving toward IPv6. This was expressed at a previous table topic discussion at ARIN 56 I believe.
>
> At least one participant asked if it was possible for ARIN to provide a report on where waitlist allocations go after they are fulfilled. Specifically, do they go to small ISPs, wind up in the market for leasing, or elsewhere?
>
> It was also mentioned that if an entity has a viable business plan that requires IPv4 then they should have included the cost for purchasing or leasing those resources because the Waitlist has no guarantees for available IPv4 resources, so does there remain any reason to maintain a Waitlist becomes the question.
> _________________________________________________________________________________
>
> _
> Brian Jones
> ARIN Advisory Council
> NRPM WG Chair
> _______________________________________________
> ARIN-PPML
> You are receiving this message because you are subscribed to
> the ARIN Public Policy Mailing List (ARIN-PPML at arin.net).
> Unsubscribe or manage your mailing list subscription at:
> https://lists.arin.net/mailman/listinfo/arin-ppml
> Please contact info at arin.net if you experience any issues.