[arin-ppml] ARIN 58 Table Topic - Policy Engagement WG Discussion Notes
Charlie Fish
charlie at rrainn.com
Sat Nov 14 14:31:22 EST 2026
Hi everyone,
I’m very supportive of exploring a more modern platform for ARIN
policy discussions. Following multiple threads on a single policy
through email can be difficult, and a more accessible, organized
interface could make it easier for more people to participate.
That said, I’d strongly encourage ARIN to consider Discourse rather
than Discord. Discourse provides a searchable, publicly accessible
forum while also supporting participation through email. That could
give people a choice without requiring those who prefer the mailing
list experience to abandon it.
I have significant concerns about using Discord for policy
development. Important discussions can get buried in chat history,
public access and discovery are more limited, and ARIN would be
relying on a proprietary platform it does not control. Preserving a
complete, independently accessible record and tracking proposals,
revisions, and outcomes would also be more complicated.
Discourse would not automatically solve all of those problems. ARIN
would still need a clear process for linking discussions to proposals
and decisions, and a plan for preserving and exporting the historical
record. But I think it would provide a stronger foundation for an
open, durable policy process while making it easier to participate.
I realize the survey has closed, but I hope this feedback is still
useful as the working group continues its exploration.
Thanks,
Charlie
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 08:52:49 -0700, Matthew Wilder via ARIN-PPML
<arin-ppml at arin.net> wrote:
> Hi PPML subscribers,
>
> As with other table topic discussions held by the advisory council, we are
> continuing to post summaries of those discussions to the mailing list for
> the benefit of the community.
>
> We held a table topic at ARIN 58 around the topic of policy engagement,
> focused on the concept of introducing an online community discussion
> platform to facilitate policy discussions rather than strict reliance on
> PPML between meetings. The following notes were recorded from those
> discussions:
>
> --- (begin notes) ---
>
> - We heard comments the effect that email is not ideal for participants
> attempting to track a variety of parallel threads on one policy, which
> often result in a disjointed set of emails to navigate through
>
> - Newer platforms which facilitate "micro-reactions" via reactions will
> invite more participation, especially with new participants
>
> - One participant pointed out that we do need to be careful with the
> "thumbs up" emoji which can sometimes convey acknowledgement rather than
> agreement
>
> - There were comments that the meetings often include more involvement
> from more involved members of the community, who often share very relevant
> context, describing why a policy was originally introduced
>
> - We discussed the idea of having new ways of surfacing that context:
> 1 In meetings: in the policy presentations
> 2 Online: exposing that history through references to relevant draft
> policies which introduced and modified those sections
> 3 Online: an interactive LLM trained on the NRPM and historical drafts to
> summarize relevant policy discussions
>
> - It was noted that some new mailing list tools might offer some of the
> capabilities we are discussing
>
> - Generally there was a receptive response to continuing the exploration
> into new ways of engaging with the community (surveys, platforms, etc)
>
> --- (this concludes the notes from the table topic discussion) ---
>
> Additionally, please be reminded that our survey of the community to
> solicit feedback specifically around this topic is open now, and will
> remain open until November 13. If you have not yet recorded your feedback,
> please consider taking 5 - 10 minutes to do so:
>
> https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/Policy-Engagement-Survey-Part2
>
> Thanks in advance!
>
> Matthew
More information about the ARIN-PPML
mailing list