[arin-ppml] Addressing for other planets

[Tony Li]

Hi John,


> As noted, I remain unclear about the aggregation properties of your Outer Space/Celestial Body-based allocation scheme (as opposed to allocations that follow and thus naturally aggregate within the network topology of agency space networks), but understand that further clarity is unlikely to be obtained without some actual hard parameters and modeling.  You assert a gain in aggregation, and let’s take that as given assumption for the time being. 


Two words for you to meditate on: nested abstraction.


> Now the world is a dynamic place, and as a result, let’s hypothecate some of the questions that arise in the early years of operation –


All of the points that you make below are largely the same as for any ISP.  I don’t see why you’re making this molehill into a mountain.  I get that they are important and I acknowledge that they will take work, but I don’t see them as a serious impediment.

I get that you don’t wanna do this. I don’t understand why.

Regards,
Tony