[arin-ppml] [EXT] Re: Open Petition for ARIN-prop-266: BGP Hijacking is an ARIN Policy Violation

[Marilson Mapa]

Ø  If organizations violate their legal agreements with you, then that’s a
matter for the legal system, not ARIN.

Ø  ARIN is not law enforcement agency, but rather a Regional Internet
Registry.

REGISTRATION SERVICES AGREEMENT – ARIN-RSA

13. TERM AND TERMINATION

(b) Suspension of Services or Termination of Agreement for Cause by ARIN.
ARIN shall have the right to suspend Services without notice to Holder if
Holder breaches any of Sections 2(c), 2(d), 4 or 7. In addition, ARIN may
immediately suspend Services upon written notice to Holder pursuant to
Section 2(e) or if Holder breaches Section 2(d) or Section 11.

Sections 2(d):

(d) Prohibited Conduct By Holder. In using any of the Services, Holder
shall not: (i) disrupt or interfere with the security or use of any of the
Services; (ii) violate any applicable laws, statutes, rules, or
regulations; or (iii) assist any third party in engaging in any activity
prohibited by any Service Terms.

(e) Cooperation With Government Authority. ARIN shall have the right,
without liability or notice to Holder, to cooperate and comply with all
applicable laws, statutes, rules, or regulations.

5. CURRENT AND FUTURE POLICIES: Pursuant to ARIN’s Policy Development
Process (“PDP”), ARIN maintains the Policies and may at any time in its
sole and absolute discretion amend the Policies, implement new policies
(which once amended or implemented, becomes part of the Policies), or
revoke existing Policies.

7. NO PROPERTY RIGHTS: Holder acknowledges and agrees that: (a) the
Included Number Resources are not property (real, personal, or
intellectual) of Holder;

It is your rules granted by a contract signed between the parties. Once
signed they are rights, but they are also duties and obligations legal and
moral. Regardless of the existence of a contract, as a citizen you have a
moral obligation to demand ethical behavior from those who use the tools
you have made available. Run away from your responsibilities and you will
be complicit.

"Fraud will not be tolerated. The vast majority of organizations obtain
their address space from ARIN in good faith according to the policies set
out by the community. However, ARIN detected fraud as a result of internal
due diligence processes, and took action to respond in this particularly
egregious case," said John Curran, ARIN President and CEO. "We are stepping
up our efforts to actively investigate suspected cases of fraud against
ARIN and will revoke resources and report unlawful activity to law
enforcement whenever appropriate."

Fraud will not be tolerated when it occurs against the community. But it is
widely tolerated if it is against the populations. It seems that "police"
actions are only out of scope when they will reduce community profits. To
hell with the world!

Marilson

Em qui, 23 de mai de 2019 às 15:43, John Curran <jcurran at arin.net> escreveu:

> On 23 May 2019, at 5:46 PM, Marilson Mapa <marilson.mapa at gmail.com> wrote:
>
> ... If ISPs and Registrars behaved like stated in their AUPs and ToSs, and
> the RIRs and ICANN required their customers to act accordingly, they would
> not be on the crime pages of the newspapers. But they would be far less
> rich. So... out of the scope!
>
>
> Marilson -
>
> If organizations violate their legal agreements with you, then that’s a
> matter for the legal system, not ARIN.
>
> ARIN is not law enforcement agency, but rather a Regional Internet
> Registry.
>
> Mr. Router, will the "768K day" happen? On May 1st, 700 billion spam were
> trafficked. What is the new goal? A trillion a day? You are experts at
> pissing people off, are not you? What a sick profession! After an
> exhausting day irritating people, can you sleep at night? Sociopaths can do
> it!
>
>
> That's it Mr. John Curran. Feel free to do what you have to do because you
> no longer have any use for me.
>
> To the extent that you can respectfully contribute to the number resource
> policy discussions on this mailing list, you are more than welcome to do so.
>
> I would suggest, however, that you refrain from the acerbic dialogue and
> instead focus your efforts on making specific suggestions on the draft
> policies under consideration.
>
> Thanks!
> /John
>
> John Curran
> President and CEO
> American Registry for Internet Numbers
>
>
>
>
>
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.arin.net/pipermail/arin-ppml/attachments/20190523/a34a5dff/attachment.htm>