[arin-ppml] NRPM 4.10 - is a /10 large enough?

[Bill Owens]

On Tue, Apr 29, 2014 at 11:13:26AM -0700, Andrew Dul wrote:
> Policy proposal 207, suggests that we add to the existing /10 reserved
> pool with the fragments that we will get back from IANA shortly.  It
> appears ARIN will received somewhere between a /11 and /10 equivalent
> when the fragments are distributed.  The proposal also limits the number
> of allocations to one per organization.

I saw 207 mentioned in the "Ip allocation" thread but thought that it was a parallel of 4.10 for initial assigmnents, not an extension of 4.10. And now that I read it carefully, I am still more confused since it actually seems to be both. I would support the addition of the IANA recovered space to the pool, but not the fundamental change in purpose from being a transition aid to being a source of v4 space only for new entrants. 

Bill.