[arin-ppml] Additional modifications to Section 8.3 related to ASN's and legacy addresses
jcurran at arin.net
Wed May 23 02:12:20 EDT 2012
On May 23, 2012, at 12:30 AM, Martin Hannigan wrote:
.3.4 Notice of Refusal
ARIN will provide a written and detailed notice that includes the
specific reasons why when refusing any number resource or ASN transfer. This
notice will be provided to all parties to a transfer.
It is generally the recipient who has difficulty qualifying during a transfer,
and while the specific reason is often "Recipient can't demonstrate need
in accordance with policy", the proposed language suggests that more
detailed information should be returned to both the current resource holder
and intended recipient. If that is the case, then it is important to note that
this information may contain technical & business planning information of
the intended recipient which is only known to ARIN via NDA and therefore
not readily releasable.
Of course, this may not be as frequent an issue given the legacy aspects
of the proposed policy change, but as written, the notice would appear
to apply to transfers of any resources and may run afoul of NDA terms
unless this disclosure is very clearly specified in the proposed policy,
and specifically authorized in advance by intended recipients when
applying to transfer resources. Supplying this information to only the
recipient would not cause this problem (and we presently do provide
that information in the request ticket) but that may not meet your goals
for the proposed policy change.
President and CEO
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the ARIN-PPML