[arin-ppml] CGN multiplier was: RE: Input on an article by Geoff Huston (potentially/myopically off-topic addendum)

Chris Engel cengel at conxeo.com
Wed Sep 14 17:04:45 EDT 2011

> Initially you seem to be implying that foolish gamblers shouldn't be bailed
> out. But here you can only be suggesting that crooked and/or stupid
> gambling hall operators should also be at liberty to swindle as many people as
> they can, and to cover up their criminality any means at their disposal for as
> long as they can, until finally everyone else wises up somehow.


I'm not sure how you can actualy get that conclusion from what I was saying.  I don't condone dishonesty, theft or fraud. There is a very large difference between engaging in activities that are dishonest and engaging in those which imprudent, risky or just plain stupid. It's the difference between tresspassing against someone elses rights and excersizing your own.  A financial instiution shouldn't be allowed to tell someone that they are investing thier money, do no such thing and pocket it. A financial instution should be allowed to excersize thier own judgement about what makes a good investment, as long as they inform the investor as to what's being done with thier money, it really should be no one elses business.

In network terms, my obligation to you ends at the network boundary. If I send traffic to you, I have an obligation to let you know that traffic came from my network. I don't feel any obligation to let you know exactly how I got it to you....or even the individual device/part of my network that it came from. If that makes such traffic not usefull to you, you are free not to carry it.

Christopher Engel 

More information about the ARIN-PPML mailing list