[arin-ppml] transfer conditions

[Owen DeLong]

On May 6, 2011, at 2:04 PM, John Curran wrote:

> On May 2, 2011, at 4:32 PM, Owen DeLong wrote:
> 
>> 1.  Org. A has a /8 and wants to transfer 32 of it's constituent /24s to Org. B.
>>   However, Org. A doesn't want to put any effort into renumbering,
>>   so, those 32 /24s are each individual non-aggregable /24s.
>> 
>>   This transfer should not be allowed.
> 
> Owen - 
> 
>   I'm going to rework your example a little bit to assist in
>   my understanding of your position:
> 
>   If an Org X has two blocks: a /16 (NETX16) and a /24 (NETX24), & they 
>   approach ARIN and indicate that they want to transfer a /24 portion 
>   of NETX16 to Org Y, ARIN should disallow it?  Does that answer change
>   if NETX24 is in already heavily in use by Org B?  What if NETX24 is 
>   in use, and it's a part in an embedded system already in the field?
>   What if NETX24 is in use by another business unit than the one which
>   holds the NETX16?
> 
Ideally:

Yes... No... No... No.

Realistically, probably hard to enforce beyond:

No... No... No... No.

Owen