[arin-ppml] ARIN-prop-154 Shared Space for IPv4 Address Extension (w/IETF considerations) - Staff Comments

[Joe Maimon]

Owen DeLong wrote:

>
> The IAB advised that allocating the space would be contrary to RFC 2860.
> They did not address the issue of identifying, reserving it and setting it
> aside without allocating it which is what proposal 154 specifies.

Tell me how an identified reservation contrasts positively with an 
actual allocation. You risk a de-facto allocation with none of the 
benefits of an actual allocation.

>
> I am concerned that there may or may not be a /10 block available by the time

I believe this should be addressed with an unidentifiable reservation.

> Owen


Joe