[arin-ppml] Policy Proposal: Sunset Clause for Liberalized Transfer Policy

[Seth Mattinen]

Milton L Mueller wrote:
>> One could also say the sunset is a compromise between the two 
>> extremes. 
> 
> it's the kind of compromise that cuts the baby in half. 
> if folks can demonstrate real problems with transfers they should have no trouble re-opening the issue. 
> 
>> Arbitrary transfers are also arbitrary.
> 
> unassailable verbal logic (as are all tautologies), but I honestly don't get your point.
> 

You said a sunset was arbitrary; I'm saying 2009-1 was arbitrary too. I
also stopped reading the long thread it generated after a while of all
the back and forth, so maybe I missed something.

~Seth