[ppml] Posting of Legacy RSA and FAQ

Randy Bush randy at psg.com
Sun Oct 14 00:57:17 EDT 2007

amusingly one-sided.
  o arin may terminate if holder does not...  but nothing about if arin
    does not
  o arin may choose to ignore change request, which may be solely why
    the holder is interested in doing this at all
  o 4d si all about holder following laws, ... but nothing about arin
    doing so
  o 5b says holder responsible for accurate whois, but 4b makes clear
    that arin controls all data, and thereby may prevent compliance
  o and on and on and on

if this was drawn two parties negotiating a fair win-win contract, it
would be far more balanced.  but this is a "my way or the highway"
contract drawn by one party thinking it controls all the cards.

maybe in a few iterations, when it is less one-sided and arrogant, i
will think about spending a lawyer's time looking at it.


More information about the ARIN-PPML mailing list