[ppml] Difference between ULA-C and PI
Ed.Lewis at neustar.biz
Fri Jun 8 11:38:15 EDT 2007
I'm not going to compare PI to ULA-C as the latter isn't well defined
(no draft) - but - for the sake of seeing if I'm understanding the
Comparing PI and to some addressing scheme that is purported to not
be in the DFZ:
1) Both are the same amount of work and benefit to the RIRS.
2) PI puts a route into the DFZ, the other thing doesn't.
The latter point makes the non-routed address scheme less "costly" to
network operations. OTOH, as both are the same in the registration
process I would think that they are the same under all other RIR
policies (cost sharing, reporting, whois/in-addr, etc.)
At least this is what I have gathered from reading the threads on this.
Edward Lewis +1-571-434-5468
Sarcasm doesn't scale.
More information about the ARIN-PPML