[ppml] Policy without consensus?
woody at pch.net
Mon Jan 23 17:09:57 EST 2006
On Mon, 23 Jan 2006, Howard, W. Lee wrote:
> > Well, the last PP 2005-1 was completely unworkable. I
> > supported it because
> > it was better than nothing - but only barely. (Many) People
> > who voted for it
> > were holding their noses and voting yes in the hope of
> > improving it later.
Yup, that's certainly true of me, and of everyone else I know who voted
for it. It wasn't acceptable as voted, but there was nothing else on the
table, and nothing else we could vote for. Yes, that's a really major
> That puts us in a difficult position. The process says we can
> only ratify a policy is there is evidence of consensus. The
> only exception would be in case of an emergency, and I think
> we're a couple of years from an emergency.
I think we're a couple of years into an emergency.
More information about the ARIN-PPML