[ppml] PI Assignment Survey Results

[Andrew Dul]

Here is a copy of the survey results from those who choose to participate.  

You can also see the results in graphical form here:
     http://www.quark.net/survey/results.php?sid=28

Andrew

-------------------------------------


   1.  I support the creation of a IPv6 Provider Independent Address Policy.
Strongly Agree		 	- 	19 	59.38% 
Agree 				   - 	6 	18.75% 
Neither agree nor disagree 	- 	1 	3.13%  
Disagree 			- 	3 	9.38%  
Strongly Disagree 		- 	3 	9.38%  
Total Answers 			- 	32


  2.  I support an IPv6 PI assignment to any organization which qualifies for an IPv4 assignment.
Strongly Agree 			- 	12 	36.36% 
Agree 				- 	10 	30.30% 
Neither agree nor disagree 	- 	1 	3.03%  
Disagree 			- 	6 	18.18% 
Strongly Disagree 		- 	4 	12.12% 
Total Answers 			- 	33


  3.  I support an IPv6 PI policy which requires other criteria. (Other than any IPv4 assignment)
Strongly Agree 			- 	7 	21.21%  
Agree			 	- 	11 	33.33%  
Neither agree nor disagree 	- 	8 	24.24%  
Disagree 			- 	5 	15.15%  
Strongly Disagree 		- 	2 	6.06%  
Total Answers 			- 	33


  4.  Should the requirement of "end-site" as defined in the current IPv6 policy be a requirement for a PI assignment?
Yes 		- 	10 	33.33% 
No 		- 	20 	66.67% 
Total Answers 	- 	30


  5.  I support the requirement that an organization must be multihomed to qualify for an IPv6 PI assignment.
Agree 				- 	22 	66.67%  
Neither agree nor disagree 	- 	4 	12.12%  
Disagree 			- 	7 	21.21%  
Total Answers 			- 	33


  6.  I support the requirement that an organization must have a current IPv4 assignment to qualify for an IPv6 PI assignment.
Agree 				- 	5 	15.15% 
Neither agree nor disagree 	- 	15 	45.45%  
Disagree 			- 	13 	39.39%  
Total Answers 			- 	33


  7.  What size of IPv4 assignment should the organization have to qualify for an IPv6 PI assignment?
/24 		- 	2 	6.45%  
/23 		- 	0 	0.00%  
/22	 	- 	6 	19.35%  
/21 		- 	1 	3.23%  
/20 		- 	3 	9.68%  
/19 		- 	4 	12.90% 
/18 		- 	0 	0.00%  
/17 		- 	0 	0.00%  
/16 		- 	5 	16.13%  
No Preference 	- 	10 	32.26%  
Total Answers 	- 	31


  8.  I support the requirement to assign IPv6 PI address space from a seperate super block.
Agree 				- 	19 	59.38%  
Neither agree nor disagree 	- 	9 	28.13%  
Disagree 			- 	4 	12.50%  
Total Answers 			- 	32


  9.  I support a minimum size for an IPv6 PI address assignment.
Agree 				- 	26 	78.79%  
Neither agree nor disagree 	- 	4 	12.12%  
Disagree 			- 	3 	9.09%  
Total Answers 			- 	33


  10.  What should be the minimum assignment size?
/40 		- 	4 	12.50%  
/44 		- 	1 	3.13%  
/48 		- 	20 	62.50% 
/64 		- 	2 	6.25%  
No Preference 	- 	5 	15.63%  
Total Answers 	- 	32


  11.  I support a maximum assignment size.
Agree 				- 	8 	25.81% 
Neither agree nor disagree 	- 	10 	32.26% 
Disagree 			- 	13 	41.94% 
Total Answers 			- 	31


  12.  What should be the maximum assignment size?
/32 		- 	2 	8.33%  
/36 		- 	1 	4.17%  
/40 		- 	6 	25.00% 
/48 		- 	3 	12.50% 
No Preference 	- 	12 	50.00% 
Total Answers 	- 	24


  13.  I support the requirement to specify a reserved block in an IPv6 PI address policy.
Agree 				- 	13 	40.63%  
Neither agree nor disagree 	- 	12 	37.50%  
Disagree 			- 	7 	21.88%  
Total Answers 			- 	32


  14.  What should be the reserved block size?
/32	 	- 	5 	17.24%  
/44 		- 	7 	24.14% 
/46 		- 	1 	3.45%  
No Preference 	- 	16 	55.17%  
Total Answers 	- 	29


  15.  I support the assignment of additional /48 subnets to organizations with multiple assigned ASNs.
Agree 				- 	18 	54.55%  
Neither agree nor disagree 	- 	8 	24.24%  
Disagree 			- 	7 	21.21%  
Total Answers 			- 	33


  16.  I support the assignment of multiple /48s per organization.
Agree 				- 	19 	57.58%  
Neither agree nor disagree 	- 	8 	24.24%  
Disagree 			- 	6 	18.18%  
Total Answers 			- 	33


  17.  Do you support ARIN Policy Proposal 2005-1 as currently written?
Yes 		- 	18 	56.25%  
No 		- 	14 	43.75%  
Total Answers 	- 	32


  18.  Do you support ARIN Policy Proposal 2006-4 as currently written?
Yes 		- 	14 	43.75%  
No 		- 	18 	56.25%  
Total Answers 	- 	32

  20.  Which of the following best describes your affiliation?
Internet Service Provider 	- 	14 	43.75% 
Equipment Vendor 		- 	1 	3.13%  
Network Operator 		- 	2 	6.25%  
Education & Research 		- 	1 	3.13%  
Software Vendor 		- 	1 	3.13%  
Large Enterprise 		- 	5 	15.63% 
Small Enterprise 		- 	1 	3.13%  
Government 			- 	0 	0.00%  
Content Provider 		- 	3 	9.38%  
Non-Profit Organization 	- 	1 	3.13%  
Consultant 			-	2 	6.25%  
Internet User 			- 	0 	0.00%  
Other 				- 	1 	3.13%  
Total Answers 			- 	32