[ppml] Policy Proposal 2004-3 point of order

Houle, Joseph D (Joe), CMO jdhoule at att.com
Tue Apr 19 14:08:13 EDT 2005

Michael et al:
    Thank you for the clarification.   The advise you seem to be giving
is that reading the policy manual and trying to interpret the actual
policy based exclusively on those words is misguided.   One must also
read the applicable RFC(s) and make an interpretation across the history
of applicable documents.
    Sorry for the distraction, but thanks for the history lesson.
	Joe Houle

-----Original Message-----

Here is the chronology that you claim:

RFC 2050 - yes
Old Wording - no
New Wording - yes

But there is no record of ARIN ever introducing a policy that
went against RFC 2050 in this regard. Therefore, I believe that
you are simply confused and are misinterpreting the policy based
on the old wording. The new wording clears up this misunderstanding
to restate the policy from RFC 2050 that has always been the 
operative policy.

--Michael Dillon


More information about the ARIN-PPML mailing list