[ppml] comments on 2004-8
billd at cait.wustl.edu
Fri Apr 15 12:15:23 EDT 2005
Definitely....we should always keep operational issues out of policy.
We've done a bad job of that over the years....I'm involved in the
blame...as I have been in it from the beginning, but we're getting better.
ARIN Advisory Council
> -----Original Message-----
> From: owner-ppml at arin.net [mailto:owner-ppml at arin.net] On
> Behalf Of Edward Lewis
> Sent: Friday, April 15, 2005 11:00 AM
> To: Sweeting, John
> Cc: 'Edward Lewis'; ppml at arin.net
> Subject: RE: [ppml] comments on 2004-8
> Looks good or better. The intent (within the context of ARIN
> discussions) is to shield ARIN from having to alert, say, the gTLDs.
> I might suggest this, moving mention of a specific mechanism (web
> sites) from a requirement to an example.
> 4. Announcement of IANA Allocations
> The IANA, the NRO, and the RIRs will make announcements regarding an
> allocation made by the IANA to an RIR. Announcements will be made
> public via appropriate means, such as web sites and notification
> lists. ICANN and the NRO will establish administrative procedures to
> manage this process.
> At 11:45 -0400 4/15/05, Sweeting, John wrote:
> >Ed, does the language in the proposal now meet your request below:
> >4. Announcement of IANA Allocations
> >The IANA, the NRO, and the RIRs will make announcements and update
> >their respective web sites regarding an allocation made by
> the IANA to
> >an RIR. ICANN and the NRO will establish administrative
> procedures to
> >manage this process.
> >-----Original Message-----
> >From: Edward Lewis [mailto:Ed.Lewis at neustar.biz]
> >Sent: 14 avril 2005 11:18
> >To: ppml at arin.net
> >Cc: ed.lewis at neustar.biz
> >Subject: [ppml] comments on 2004-8
> ># 4. Announcement of IANA allocations to the RIRs
> ># When address space is allocated to a RIR, the IANA will send a
> >detailed # announcement to the receiving RIR. The IANA will
> also make
> >announcements # to all other RIRs, informing them of the recent
> >allocation. The RIRs will # coordinate announcements to their
> >respective membership lists and any other # lists they deem
> >This issue came up in discussing a similar policy for IPv4
> by ICANN's
> >gTLD constituency:
> ># The suggestion relates to the second sentence of the first
> >of # Section 4:"The IANA will also make announcements to all other
> >RIRs, # informing them of the recent allocation."
> >So, I'd suggest adding a sentence stating that "IANA will
> also announce
> >the allocation to other interested parties."
> >This is something that IANA ought to do, not the RIR's. The RIR's
> >don't have the relationships with gTLDs, ccTLDs, etc., etc.,
> that IANA
> >Edward Lewis
> >If you knew what I was thinking, you'd understand what I was saying.
> Edward Lewis
> If you knew what I was thinking, you'd understand what I was saying.
More information about the ARIN-PPML