[ppml] cable policy refresh
Ron da Silva
ron at aol.net
Wed Dec 24 12:21:05 EST 2003
We've been kicking around some issues wrt open cable and the current
cable allocation policy. Feedback/interest would be welcomed to
determine if/how the cable policy might need an updated. Attached is
some of the background discussion and one suggested draft policy
amendment. We're looking for input to determine level of interest.
-------------- next part --------------
Current initial cable allocation policy is based on homes passed.
Subsequent allocations are based on efficient utilization of previous
allocations. Where MSOs are providing ip addresses under an open
cable architecture for non-affiliated ISPs offering services over
the cable infrastructure, for routing, security or other policy reasons
there may be a need to utilize discrete blocks for each ISP's
DHCP pool. Varying levels utilization within those discrete blocks
may decrease overall utilization, and thus negatively impact the
MSOs ability to obtain and assign address blocks to additional
markets or other participating ISPs. The current policy does not
explicitly recognize the discrete blocks and instead determines
efficient utilization based on all assignments, regardless of
individual ISP utilizations.
There also exists a multiple discrete networks policy that
recognizes independent blocks. Future allocations are determine
by generally efficient utilization of all past allocation as well
as some normalization based on the efficient utilization of each
Should MSOs be able to combine the two existing policies to
accommodate their needs for discrete blocks in open cable architectures?
Should the current cable allocation policy be updated to reflect
Amendment to the Cable Address Space Policy
ARIN members obtaining address allocations under the Cable Address
Space Policy who additionally are providing open access to their cable
subscribers may request discrete blocks of addresses under this
amendment so that each set of discrete blocks may be evaluated
independently for justification and utilization according to the
Cable Address Space Policy.
More information about the ARIN-PPML