[consult] Community Consultation - Daily Publication of IP Addresses Issued and Returned

[Stotyn, Mel]

Member Services wrote:
> ARIN would like to consult the community on the merits of the second 
> part of Suggestion 2008-2 [excerpt below, full suggestion at bottom]:
>
> "In addition, ARIN should publish a report of addresses returned, and 
> addresses issued, in the form of a mailing list (with daily email) and

> an RSS feed. This will only contain allocations/assignments made 
> directly by ARIN or address blocks returned to ARIN's free pool. The 
> intent is that RBL operators can subscribe to such a feed and keep
their 
> own lists clean."
>
> Although there is some merit in allowing the community prompt
visibility 
> to both the IP blocks being returned to ARIN's available pool of 
> addresses and the IP blocks being issued by ARIN to the community, we 
> also see this as a potential target for abuse. Specifically, certain 
> parties may take the opportunity to use and announce IP addresses from

> these ranges without having the administrative authority to do so.  To

> that end, there are two questions we like to ask the community:
>
> 1) Does the community think that the merits of this proposal outweigh 
> the potential for abuse?
>
> 2) If the merits do outweigh the abuse, what sorts of suggestions do
you 
> have to mitigate potential for abuse?

1) Yes
2) Perhaps the list could be published to an accredited list of existing
list maintainers, such as Team-Cymru.org. Then ISPs could continue to
use current practices with more confidence that the lists are current.
These accredited list maintainers should not be allowed to turn that
privileged position into a revenue stream though.

Mel Stotyn 
Senior Operations Specialist 
ENMAX Envision Inc. 
mailto:mstotyn at enmax.com 
Phone: 403 514-3443

************************************************************************
This e-mail message is intended only for the person(s) named above and
may contain confidential or privileged information. If you are not the
person named or have not been authorized by them to access their mail,
please notify the sender immediately and delete this e-mail and any 
attachments without reading, saving, or forwarding.
************************************************************************