NAIPR Message

50 States of ARIN

Comments List Members:

        As a new member to the list, and a non-engineer, it seems like
creating more distributed services is in the spirit of what the internet is
all about.  Hasn't the benefit to society of internet been in the
facilitation of communications between individual people who use a computer
to access digital energy from some humanly influenced (or created) source?

        If so, facilitating communications by 'opening up' or changing the
paradigm of central-control to decentralized-control seems to follow all of
the trends that are occurring technologically (smaller, faster, cheaper,
lighter, easier for users), as well as on the organizational levels
(empowerment of workers, incentivizing workers etc.)
        I'd like to see (or hear) the discussion list members comments.  If
one follows this line of thinking and logic by observing what is and has
been occurring in the real world, then the idea of cloning seems to make
sense because the more access points, the "richer" the diverse benefits
which might accrue to the overall "system" can be.  This unpredictabililty
is exactly what caused all of the excitement when Netscape entered the
picture as a counter-balance to the centrally-controlled "CommerceNet
Consortium", whose purpose was to 'manage and control' the evolution of
commercial activity on the 'net.
        As we have seen, CommerceNet has had their relevance taken away by
forces which are controllable, Netscape ushered into existence a vibrant
industry where lots of companies have been formed, and value created.  This
seems to be a similar process taking place with IP Numbers.  Having
witnessed the painful process which CommerceNet had gone through, I would
hate to see ARIN make the same mistakes.  Unfortunately, after briefly
scanning the Proposal, I recognized some of the same flawed tendency to
lean toward the 'central control' model, which has been shown NOT to work.
        I anxiously await comments.

        Steve (510-227-1650)

>Can ARIN discussion list members comment on using
>140.0.0.0 to 190.0.0.0 for 50 clones of the InterNIC
>to allocate /18 blocks to ISPs in the United States ?
>
>@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
>
>CA      0.0.0.0 IANA (RESERVED-1)
>CA      1.0.0.0 IANA (RESERVED-9)
>CA      2.0.0.0 Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA) (RESERVED)
>(NET-RESERVED-2)
>NJ      3.0.0.0 General Electric Company (NET-GE-INTERNET)
>MA      4.0.0.0 BBN Planet (NET-SATNET)
>CA      5.0.0.0 Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA) (RESERVED)
>(NET-RESERVED-5)
>AZ      6.0.0.0 Army Information Systems Center (NET-YPG-NET)
>CA      7.0.0.0 Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA) (RESERVED-11)
>MA      8.0.0.0 Bolt Beranek and Newman Inc. (NET-BBN-NET-TEMP)
>NY      9.0.0.0 IBM Corporation (NET-IBM)
>CA      10.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-6)
>CA      11.0.0.0        DoD Intel Information Systems (NET-DODIIS)
>FL      12.0.0.0        AT&T ITS (NET-ATT)
>CA      13.0.0.0        Xerox Palo Alto Research Center (NET-XEROX-NET)
>CA      14.0.0.0        Public Data Network (NET-PDN)
>CA      15.0.0.0        Hewlett-Packard Company (NET-HP-INTERNET)
>CA      16.0.0.0        Digital Equipment Corporation (NET-DEC-INTERNET)
>CA      17.0.0.0        Apple Computer, Inc. (NET-APPLE-WWNET)
>MA      18.0.0.0        Massachusetts Institute of Technology (NET-MIT-TEMP)
>MI      19.0.0.0        Ford Motor Company (NET-FINET)
>VA      20.0.0.0        Computer Sciences Corporation (NET-CSC)
>VA      21.0.0.0        DDN-RVN (NET-DDN-RVN)
>DC      22.0.0.0        Defense Information Systems Agency (NET-DISNET)
>CA      23.0.0.0        IANA (NET-DDN-TC-NET)
>CA      24.0.0.0        @Home Network (NETBLK-ATHOME)   ATHOME  24.0.0.0 -
>24.3.255.0
>UK      25.0.0.0        Royal Signals and Radar Establishment (NET-RSRE-EXP)
>VA      26.0.0.0        Defense Information Systems Agency (NET-MILNET)
>CA      27.0.0.0        Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA)
>(RESERVED-10)
>VA      28.0.0.0        ARPA DSI JPO (NET-DSI-NORTH)
>DC      29.0.0.0        Defense Information Systems Agency (NET-MILX25-TEMP)
>DC      30.0.0.0        Defense Information Systems Agency (NET-ARPAX25-TEMP)
>CA      31.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-12)
>Norway  32.0.0.0        Norsk Informasjonsteknologi (NET-NORGESNETT)
>OH      33.0.0.0        DLA Systems Automation Center (NET-DCMC)
>TX      34.0.0.0        Halliburton Company (NET-HALLIBURTON)
>MI      35.0.0.0        Merit Network Inc. (NET-MERIT)
>CA      36.0.0.0        Stanford University (NET-SU-NET-TEMP)
>CA      37.0.0.0        Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA)
>(RESERVED-37A)
>VA      38.0.0.0        Performance Systems International (NET-PSINETA)
>CA      39.0.0.0        Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA)
>(RESERVED-39A)
>IN      40.0.0.0        Eli Lilly and Company (NET-LILLY-NET)
>CA      41.0.0.0        Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (RESERVED-41A)
>CA      42.0.0.0        Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA)
>(RESERVED) (NET-RESERVED-42)
>Japan   43.0.0.0        Japan Inet (NET-JAPAN-A)
>CA      44.0.0.0        Amateur Radio Digital Communications (NET-AMPRNET)
>CA      45.0.0.0        Interop Show Network (NET-SHOWNETA)
>MA      46.0.0.0        Bolt Beranek and Newman Inc. (NET-BBNNET)
>Canada  47.0.0.0        Bell-Northern Research (NET-BNR)
>NY      48.0.0.0        Prudential Securities Inc. (NET-PRUBACHE)
>        49.0.0.0        No match for "49.0.0.0".
>        50.0.0.0        No match for "50.0.0.0".
>UK      51.0.0.0        Department of Social Security of UK (NET-ITSANET)
>DE      52.0.0.0        E.I. duPont de Nemours and Co., Inc. (NET-DUPONT1)
>Germany 53.0.0.0        cap debis ccs (NET-DB-NET2)
>NJ      54.0.0.0        Merck and Co., Inc. (NET-MERCK2)
>VA      55.0.0.0        Army National Guard Bureau (NET-RCAS2)
>NC      56.0.0.0        U.S. Postal Service (NET-USPS1)
>France  57.0.0.0        SITA-Societe Internationale de Telecommunications
>Aeronautiques (NET-SITA2)
>CA      58.0.0.0        Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA)
>(RESERVED) (NET-RESERVED-58)
>CA      59.0.0.0        Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA)
>(RESERVED) (NET-RESERVED-59)
>CA      60.0.0.0        Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA)
>(RESERVED) (NET-RESERVED-60)
>CA      61.0.0.0        Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA)
>(RESERVED) (NET-RESERVED-61)
>CA      62.0.0.0        Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA)
>(RESERVED) (NET-RESERVED-62)
>CA      63.0.0.0        Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA)
>(RESERVED) (NET-RESERVED-63)
>CA      64.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      65.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      66.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      67.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      68.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      69.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      70.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      71.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      72.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      73.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      74.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      75.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      76.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      77.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      78.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      79.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      80.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      81.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      82.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      83.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      84.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      85.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      86.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      87.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      88.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      89.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      90.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      91.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      92.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      93.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      94.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      95.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-7)
>CA      96.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      97.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      98.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      99.0.0.0        IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      100.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      101.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      102.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      103.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      104.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      105.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      106.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      107.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      108.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      109.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      110.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      111.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      112.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      113.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      114.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      115.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      116.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      117.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      118.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      119.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      120.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      121.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      122.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      123.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      124.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      125.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      126.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-8)
>CA      127.0.0.0       IANA (LOOPBACK)
>CA      128.0.0.0       IANA (RESERVED-3)
>        129.0.0.0       No match for "129.0.0.0".
>        130.0.0.0       No match for "130.0.0.0".
>        131.0.0.0       No match for "131.0.0.0".
>        132.0.0.0       No match for "132.0.0.0".
>APNIC   133.0.0.0       Japan Network Information Center (NETBLK-JAPANB-INET)
>        134.0.0.0       No match for "134.0.0.0".
>FL      135.0.0.0       AT&T ITS (NET-ATT-135-0-0-0-B)
>        136.0.0.0       No match for "136.0.0.0".
>        137.0.0.0       No match for "137.0.0.0".
>        138.0.0.0       No match for "138.0.0.0".
>        139.0.0.0       No match for "139.0.0.0".
>        140.0.0.0       No match for "140.0.0.0".
>        141.0.0.0       No match for "141.0.0.0".
>        142.0.0.0       No match for "142.0.0.0".
>        143.0.0.0       No match for "143.0.0.0".
>        144.0.0.0       No match for "144.0.0.0".
>        145.0.0.0       No match for "145.0.0.0".
>        146.0.0.0       No match for "146.0.0.0".
>        147.0.0.0       No match for "147.0.0.0".
>        148.0.0.0       No match for "148.0.0.0".
>        149.0.0.0       No match for "149.0.0.0".
>        150.0.0.0       No match for "150.0.0.0".
>        151.0.0.0       No match for "151.0.0.0".
>        152.0.0.0       No match for "152.0.0.0".
>        153.0.0.0       No match for "153.0.0.0".
>        154.0.0.0       No match for "154.0.0.0".
>        155.0.0.0       No match for "155.0.0.0".
>        156.0.0.0       No match for "156.0.0.0".
>        157.0.0.0       No match for "157.0.0.0".
>        158.0.0.0       No match for "158.0.0.0".
>        159.0.0.0       No match for "159.0.0.0".
>        160.0.0.0       No match for "160.0.0.0".
>        161.0.0.0       No match for "161.0.0.0".
>        162.0.0.0       No match for "162.0.0.0".
>        163.0.0.0       No match for "163.0.0.0".
>        164.0.0.0       No match for "164.0.0.0".
>        165.0.0.0       No match for "165.0.0.0".
>        166.0.0.0       No match for "166.0.0.0".
>        167.0.0.0       No match for "167.0.0.0".
>        168.0.0.0       No match for "168.0.0.0".
>        169.0.0.0       No match for "169.0.0.0".
>        170.0.0.0       No match for "170.0.0.0".
>        171.0.0.0       No match for "171.0.0.0".
>        172.0.0.0       No match for "172.0.0.0".
>        173.0.0.0       No match for "173.0.0.0".
>        174.0.0.0       No match for "174.0.0.0".
>        175.0.0.0       No match for "175.0.0.0".
>        176.0.0.0       No match for "176.0.0.0".
>        177.0.0.0       No match for "177.0.0.0".
>        178.0.0.0       No match for "178.0.0.0".
>        179.0.0.0       No match for "179.0.0.0".
>        180.0.0.0       No match for "180.0.0.0".
>        181.0.0.0       No match for "181.0.0.0".
>        182.0.0.0       No match for "182.0.0.0".
>        183.0.0.0       No match for "183.0.0.0".
>        184.0.0.0       No match for "184.0.0.0".
>        185.0.0.0       No match for "185.0.0.0".
>        186.0.0.0       No match for "186.0.0.0".
>        187.0.0.0       No match for "187.0.0.0".
>        188.0.0.0       No match for "188.0.0.0".
>        189.0.0.0       No match for "189.0.0.0".
>        190.0.0.0       No match for "190.0.0.0".
>        191.0.0.0       No match for "191.0.0.0".
>CA      192.0.0.0       IANA (NET-ROOT-NS-LAB)
>RIPE    193.0.0.0       European Regional Internet Registry/RIPE NCC
>(NETBLK-RIPE)
>RIPE    194.0.0.0       European Regional Internet Registry/RIPE NCC
>(NETBLK-RIPE-C2)
>RIPE    195.0.0.0       European Regional Internet Registry/RIPE NCC
>(NETBLK-RIPE-C)
>        196.0.0.0       No match for "196.0.0.0".
>        197.0.0.0       No match for "197.0.0.0".
>VA      198.0.0.0       InterNIC Registration (INTERNIC-BLK)
>VA      199.0.0.0       US Sprint (NETBLK-SPRINT-BLKA)
>Colombia        200.0.0.0       HOCOL S.A. (NET-SHELL-1)
>        201.0.0.0       No match for "201.0.0.0".
>APNIC   202.0.0.0       Asia Pacific Network Information Center (APNIC2)
>APNIC-CIDR-BLK
>APNIC   203.0.0.0       Asia Pacific Network Information Center (APNIC2)
>APNIC-CIDR-BLK
>TX      204.0.0.0       Rice University-Sesquinet (NETBLK-SESQUI-CIDR-03)
>DC      205.0.0.0       SPAWAR (JMCIS-BLOCK)
>FL      206.0.0.0       PSINET/Palm Coast Data (NET-NETBLK-PSI-C5-0)
>VA      207.0.0.0       MCI Internet Services (NETBLK-MCI-NETBLK08)
>TX      208.0.0.0       virtual village (NET-SPRINT-D00000)
>CA      209.0.0.0       GeoNet Communications, Inc. (NETBLK-GEO-CIDR-05)
>APNIC   210.0.0.0       Asia Pacific Network Information Center
>(NETBLK-APNIC-CIDR-BLK)
>APNIC   211.0.0.0       Asia Pacific Network Information Center
>(NETBLK-APNIC-CIDR-BLK)
>        212.0.0.0       No match for "212.0.0.0".
>        213.0.0.0       No match for "213.0.0.0".
>        214.0.0.0       No match for "214.0.0.0".
>        215.0.0.0       No match for "215.0.0.0".
>        216.0.0.0       No match for "216.0.0.0".
>        217.0.0.0       No match for "217.0.0.0".
>        218.0.0.0       No match for "218.0.0.0".
>        219.0.0.0       No match for "219.0.0.0".
>        220.0.0.0       No match for "220.0.0.0".
>        221.0.0.0       No match for "221.0.0.0".
>        222.0.0.0       No match for "222.0.0.0".
>        223.0.0.0       No match for "223.0.0.0".
>CA      224.0.0.0       University of Southern California (NET-MCAST-NET)
>        225.0.0.0       No match for "225.0.0.0".
>        226.0.0.0       No match for "226.0.0.0".
>        227.0.0.0       No match for "227.0.0.0".
>        228.0.0.0       No match for "228.0.0.0".
>        229.0.0.0       No match for "229.0.0.0".
>        230.0.0.0       No match for "230.0.0.0".
>        231.0.0.0       No match for "231.0.0.0".
>        232.0.0.0       No match for "232.0.0.0".
>        233.0.0.0       No match for "233.0.0.0".
>        234.0.0.0       No match for "234.0.0.0".
>        235.0.0.0       No match for "235.0.0.0".
>        236.0.0.0       No match for "236.0.0.0".
>        237.0.0.0       No match for "237.0.0.0".
>        238.0.0.0       No match for "238.0.0.0".
>        239.0.0.0       No match for "239.0.0.0".
>        240.0.0.0       No match for "240.0.0.0".
>        241.0.0.0       No match for "241.0.0.0".
>        242.0.0.0       No match for "242.0.0.0".
>        243.0.0.0       No match for "243.0.0.0".
>        244.0.0.0       No match for "244.0.0.0".
>        245.0.0.0       No match for "245.0.0.0".
>        246.0.0.0       No match for "246.0.0.0".
>        247.0.0.0       No match for "247.0.0.0".
>        248.0.0.0       No match for "248.0.0.0".
>        249.0.0.0       No match for "249.0.0.0".
>        250.0.0.0       No match for "250.0.0.0".
>        251.0.0.0       No match for "251.0.0.0".
>        252.0.0.0       No match for "252.0.0.0".
>        253.0.0.0       No match for "253.0.0.0".
>        254.0.0.0       No match for "254.0.0.0".
>        255.0.0.0       No match for "255.0.0.0".
>
>@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@