[arin-ppml] Statistics for NRPM 8.3 Transfers

[John Curran]

Jimmy - 
 
  I'm not trying to discourage you, but do need to point out that
  the larger the list of metrics, the longer until they are all
  available.

  Is there any prioritization to these metrics which would you
  would apply to assist you in your NRPM 8.3 policy development
  efforts?   This would also allow us to size up the development
  and documentation effort that would be entailed.

Thanks!
/John

John Curran
President and CEO
ARIN

On Jun 30, 2012, at 1:20 PM, Jimmy Hess wrote:

> I would suggest....
> 
> For each metric:   Variables: number of requests  received,  number of
> requests completed, number of requests pending but not resolved,
> number of requests rejected or deferred pending additional
> justification,  number of requests permanently rejected or withdrawn
> 
>       For each variable,  daily minimum,  maximum,  mean, median, and stddev;
>       in the number of requests falling in that category  for
> received, completed, rejected/deferred,  and  for the size of  the
> requests    in that status for that day, in
> terms of number of IPv4 addresses  (block size),
>      AND number of blocks  and total IPs per request.
> 
> Example
>   2013/01                 xxx   free pool requests received
>                                          block size of received
> requests   min=xxx,  max=xxx, avg=xxx,
>                                                mean=xxx,  median=xxx,
> stddev=xxx
>                                          number of blocks in received
> requests   min=xxx,  max=xxx, avg=xxx,
>                                                mean=xxx,  median=xxx,
> stddev=xxx
>                                          total size of the requests
> (number of IPs)   min=xxx,  max=xxx, avg=xxx,
>                                                mean=xxx,  median=xxx,
> stddev=xxx
> 
> 
>                                 xxx   free pool requests completed
>                                          block size of completed
> requests  min=........
>                                          .........
>                                 xxx   free pool requests pending/rejected
>                                              ......
>                                 xxxx   8.2 transfer requests received
>                                             .........
> 
> Categories of requests to count separately:
> For Daily, Monthly, Quarterly, Yearly,
> 
> aggregated number of IPv4 address transfer requests for each unique
> transfer originator and each unique transfer recipient,  and the
> statistics regarding the number of IPv4 addresses that they hold
> before and after transfers  on that date  (min, max, mean, median,
> stddev).
> for example
>   Yearly  2013
>                Transfer originator,  resources held prior to
> transfers during the period  avg=xxx min=xxx max=xxx med=xxx
> stddev=xxx
>                Transfer originator,  resources held after all
> transfers in the period  avg=xxx min=xxx max=xxx med=xxx  stddev=xxx
>                Transfer recipient, ...
> 
> 
> 
> 
> number of IPv4 address transfer requests to be received by an
> organization with no current RIR allocation or assignment.
>        Average  minimum,  maximum,  mean,  stddev  IP address count
> of all IPv4 assigned resources held by the transfer originator and the
> transfer recipient prior to the transfer.
>        Average  minimum,  maximum,  mean,  stddev  IP address count
> of all IPv4 allocated resources held by the transfer originator and
> the transfer recipient prior to the transfer.
> 
> 
> Daily, Monthly, Quarterly, Yearly,
> 
> number of new IPv4 resource allocation, free pool requests   & block
> size stats.
> 
> number of IPv4 address returns to ARIN  & block size stats..
> 
>  number of voluntary IPv4 address return requests to ARIN by (L)RSA
> signed resources  not  required by an aggregation request  & block
> size stats..
> 
> number of voluntary Legacy IPv4 address return requests   & block size stats..
> 
>  number of IPv4 address aggregation requests,  with return of
> addresses required and equal allocation size  & block size stats.
> 
> number of IPv4 address aggregation requests,  with return of
> addresses required and reduced allocation size  & block size stats.
> 
> number of IPv4 address aggregation requests,  with return of
> addresses required and increased allocation size  & block size stats.
> 
> 
> number of transfers of any type   & block size stats.
> 
> number of transfers facilitated through the ARIN STLS  & block size stats;
> require  that transfer recipients indicate the means that they used
> to discover
> that resources were available,  so that it is known if STLS
> facilitated the transfer being requested or not.
> 
> 
>  number of transfer requests between different RIRs  inbound,
> outbound,  & block size stats.
> 
>  number of 8.2 transfer requests   & block size stats.
> 
> Number of 8.2 transfer requests  of ISP allocations  & block size stats.
> 
> Number of 8.2 transfer requests  of end user assignments  & block size stats.
> 
> 
> number of all 8.3 transfer requests
> 
>  number of 8.3 transfer requests where a Legacy network assignment is
> requested to convert to an  assignment for transfer to an end user   &
> block size stats.
> 
>  number of 8.3 transfer requests where a Legacy network assignment is
> requested to convert to an allocation for an ISP transfer recipient
> & block size stats.
> 
> 
>   number of 8.3 transfer requests where an ARIN allocation already
> under RSA is requested to convert to an end user assignment  for the
> recipient   & block size stats.
> 
>  number of 8.3 transfer requests where an ARIN assignment already
> under RSA is requested to convert to an allocation for the ISP   &
> block size stats.
> 
>   number of 8.3 transfer requests of any type  for transfer to a
> provider allocation
>   number of 8.2 transfer requests of any type  for transfer to a
> provider allocation
> 
>   number transfer requests of any type where an assignment remains an
> assignment
>  number transfer requests of any type where an allocation remains an allocation
> 
>   number transfer requests of any type where an allocation is
> requested to convert to an assignment for an end user
> 
>   number transfer requests of any type where an assignment is
> requested to be converted to an allocation for an ISP
> 
> 
> 
> --
> -JH
> _______________________________________________
> PPML
> You are receiving this message because you are subscribed to
> the ARIN Public Policy Mailing List (ARIN-PPML at arin.net).
> Unsubscribe or manage your mailing list subscription at:
> http://lists.arin.net/mailman/listinfo/arin-ppml
> Please contact info at arin.net if you experience any issues.