[arin-ppml] ARIN-prop-171 Section 8.4Modifications:ASNandlegacy resources

[Mike Burns]

Hi John,

Just finished the Steve Ryan piece, thanks.
I wanted to share an alternate perspective from a lawyer and sometime 
contributor here on the PPML:

http://addrex.net/documents/2012/02/rubi-aipla-qj.pdf

I think the argument about property rights for legacy space is germane to 
this list, and we run the risks of creating policy in contravention of the 
law if we don't fully understand each point of view.
I think a debate between Ryan and Rubi would be more edifying than a debate 
between yourself and Prof. Mueller.
But I would buy popcorn for both.

Regards,
Mike



>Mike -

>You might also want to review this article written by Steve Ryan,
ARIN's counsel, as it addresses some of the questions regarding
how ARIN views address holders rights to number resources -
>http://www.mwe.com/info/pubs/internetprotocolnumbers0212.pdf

Thanks!
/John

John Curran
President and CEO
ARIN