ARIN-PPML Message

[arin-ppml] ARIN-prop-131: Section 5.0 Legacy Addresses - revised

On 2/11/11 12:01 CST, Martin Hannigan wrote:
....
> Thanks. If you'd like to target additional non-specific concerns, I'd
> suggest that you craft a proposal for consideration.

I probably will, I've thought of a few ideas subsequent to responding.

>I'm targeting a
> specific, highly charged, global issue and the proposal needs to be
> crystal clear.

Yep, I understand.

> Based on preliminary feedback, I believe that it is in
> it's current state.

I disagree, there is one issue that is muddying things for me still. 
Let me quote the operable part of the policy text and then I'll explain.

> Legacy IPv4 addresses returned to or recovered by ARIN will be made
> available for registration and distribution in the ARIN region within
> thirty days of their receipt.

In the first part you I think you are trying to say "treat any Legacy 
IPv4 address space returned or recovered the same way any non-legacy 
IPv4 addresses would be within the ARIN region."  It is the last part of 
the sentence "within thirty days of their receipt." that muddies things 
for me.  It is kind of saying "BUT, now treat it in this different way", 
which conflict with the intent of the beginning part.  Pull out the 30 
day clause, then it makes sense to me for this policy to be limited to 
Legacy IPv4 addresses.

However, with the 30 day clause in there I want that clause to apply to 
both Legacy and non-Legacy address space.  I actually think the 30 day 
clause is a good policy intent, but it needs to apply to both Legacy and 
non-Legacy IPv4 address space, applying it to Legacy only is bad and 
broken policy.

So, I think it is the 30 day clause that has a number of people asking 
why should this policy only apply to Legacy IPv4 address space.

> With respect to administration, I'll wait until
> the full staff and legal review before I comment, or edit, further.

Furthermore, I believe that clause without additional clarification 
creates a conflicts with contractual obligations that ARIN has with any 
organization that has signed the LRSA.

Unless, you believe that once an organization signs a LRSA its resources 
are no longer Legacy IPv4 addresses.

So, if you want to keep this policy crystal clear pull the 30 day clause 
out, then I could probably support it.

-- 
===============================================
David Farmer               Email:farmer at umn.edu
Networking & Telecommunication Services
Office of Information Technology
University of Minnesota	
2218 University Ave SE	    Phone: 612-626-0815
Minneapolis, MN 55414-3029   Cell: 612-812-9952
===============================================