[arin-ppml] Discussion Petition of ARIN-prop-125 Efficient Utilization of IPv4 Requires Dual-Stack

[Jason Schiller]

On Thu, 30 Dec 2010, Matthew Kaufman wrote:

|The proposal as-is would also prevent transfers to entities that hadn't
|deployed IPv6. So there'd be *no* transfer market during this time... except a
|grey/black one.
|
|Matthew Kaufman

Yes i agree theer would be *no* transfer market during this time... 
except a grey/black one... 

but I am not sure what your point is with this comment.

Right now all IPv4 transferes require justified need.  As ARIN does still 
fulfill requests with justified need, there should be *no* transfer 
market.  

The only people who are attempting to transfer space on the grey/black 
market are those who can't actually meet ARIN's requirements for justified 
need.


Are you argueing that we should have a liberal transfer market (no 
justified need) like the APNIC region?  Or are you trying to make some 
other point?

__Jason