[ppml] IPv6 PI Assignment Survey
> From: Marshall Eubanks <tme at multicasttech.com>
> Subject: Re: [ppml] IPv6 PI Assignment Survey
> Sent: 07 Apr '06 08:34
> Thanks for doing this.
> Two places with possible ambiguities :
> - Questions
> 2. I support an IPv6 PI assignment to any organization which
> qualifies for an IPv4 assignment.
> 3. I support an IPv6 PI policy which requires other criteria. (Other
> than any IPv4 assignment)
> are not mutually exclusive. (For example, I support a IPv6 only
> assignment policy for networks
> without a IPv4 footprint.)
> So I answered "yes" to both.
I didn't assume they were mutually exclusive so answering, yes to both is perfectly acceptable. I did that too when I added my opinion.
> - Is a minimum assignment the shortest prefix or the smallest block
> allowed ?
> (and the obvious inverse for maximum)
> I assume smallest block.
That was my assumption too. Both of the exiting policies assume /48 as the smallest block.
> On Apr 7, 2006, at 12:20 PM, Andrew Dul wrote:
> > I'd like to thank Thomas Narten for posting his messages yesterday
> > encouraging people to post their comments to PPML.
> > I also realize that not everyone can post their comments or wishes
> > to send lots of "me too" emails, but may still want to express
> > their opinion.
> > I've created an online survey where I've attempted to capture the
> > questions Thomas posted yesterday in an online form. I'm hopefully
> > that this will help the authors of the two IPv6 PI policies craft
> > an IPv6 PI policy which will gain consensus at the upcoming meeting
> > in Montreal.
> > Please take a minute and go to the following URL to fill out the
> > short survey.
> > http://www.quark.net/survey/survey.php?sid=28
> > This *not* an ARIN sponsored survey, but I will post the results of
> > data that is collected to PPML on Monday morning April 10, 2006.
> > Thanks for your participation,
> > Andrew
> > _______________________________________________
> > PPML mailing list
> > PPML at arin.net
> > http://lists.arin.net/mailman/listinfo/ppml