[ppml] 2005-1 or its logical successor

[Bill Woodcock]

      On Thu, 27 Oct 2005, Steve Feldman wrote:
    > > for the record, the straw poll was 24 vs 25.
    > ... And for what it's worth, my vote for the policy was mostly because
    > it was better than no policy at all, and hoping it could be cleaned
    > up on the way to adoption.  I was also in favor of the original 2005-1.

Right, I assume that was true of the other 22 people besides you and Dan 
Golding, as well.  I didn't hear anyone say that the revisions to 2005-1 
were acceptable, or were even _not worse_.  I did hear many, many people 
queue up at the mics and all agree that they _were much much worse_, and 
unacceptable.  

So the two people who've explained their "yes" votes have both said that 
they voted for something unacceptable, hoping it could be salvaged 
afterwards.  Hardly a ringing endorsement.  Whereas the second vote, to 
fix this, was unanimous except for Randy and Lee, both of whom were 
joking because Stacy had offered to spank them.

                                -Bill